3 minOther
Other

Motion of Thanks

What is Motion of Thanks?

The Motion of Thanks is a formal way for Parliament to thank the President for their address at the beginning of a new parliamentary session or the first session of a new year. The President's address outlines the government's policies and achievements. After the address, a motion is moved in each House of Parliament to thank the President. This motion is then debated upon. Amendments can be proposed to the motion. The government must secure the passage of the Motion of Thanks in both Houses. Its failure can lead to a government's defeat, as it indicates a lack of confidence in the government. It is mandated by Article 87 of the Indian Constitution.

Historical Background

The practice of the Motion of Thanks is derived from British parliamentary tradition. In India, it was adopted after independence with the enactment of the Constitution in 1950. The purpose was to provide a structured opportunity for Parliament to discuss and scrutinize the government's agenda as outlined by the President. Initially, the debate was more focused on thanking the President. Over time, it has evolved into a comprehensive discussion on government policies and performance. Amendments to the motion have become a common way for the opposition to raise concerns and hold the government accountable. The importance of the Motion of Thanks has grown as a tool for parliamentary oversight.

Key Points

12 points
  • 1.

    The President's address is delivered at the commencement of the first session after each general election and at the commencement of the first session of each year.

  • 2.

    The address outlines the government's policies, programs, and achievements during the preceding year and indicates the agenda for the upcoming year.

  • 3.

    After the President's address, a Motion of Thanks is moved in each House of Parliament.

  • 4.

    Members of Parliament (MPs) debate the motion, discussing the issues raised in the President's address.

  • 5.

    Amendments to the motion can be proposed by MPs to express disagreement with the government's policies or to highlight specific issues.

  • 6.

    The Prime Minister or a designated minister replies to the debate on the Motion of Thanks, addressing the concerns raised by the MPs.

  • 7.

    The motion is then put to a vote. It must be passed by both Houses of Parliament.

  • 8.

    Failure to pass the Motion of Thanks is considered a defeat for the government and can lead to a vote of no-confidence.

  • 9.

    The Motion of Thanks provides an opportunity for the opposition to scrutinize the government's performance and hold it accountable.

  • 10.

    The scope of the debate is very wide, covering virtually every aspect of governance.

  • 11.

    The Speaker/Chairman decides on the admissibility of amendments to the Motion of Thanks.

  • 12.

    The time allotted for the debate on the Motion of Thanks is decided by the Business Advisory Committee of each House.

Visual Insights

Motion of Thanks Procedure

Illustrates the steps involved in the Motion of Thanks procedure in the Indian Parliament.

  1. 1.President's Address to Parliament
  2. 2.Motion of Thanks Moved in Each House
  3. 3.Debate on the Motion
  4. 4.Amendments Proposed (Optional)
  5. 5.Prime Minister's Reply
  6. 6.Vote on the Motion
  7. 7.Motion Passed or Rejected

Recent Developments

5 developments

In 2020, the debate on the Motion of Thanks was extended to allow for more discussion on the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA).

In recent years, there has been increasing disruption during the President's address and the subsequent debate on the Motion of Thanks.

The current news highlights a departure from convention where the Prime Minister skipped the reply to the Motion of Thanks citing security concerns.

Disallowing the Leader of Opposition from citing excerpts from a book during the debate has also raised concerns about parliamentary freedom.

There are ongoing discussions about reforming parliamentary procedures to ensure more effective scrutiny of the government.

This Concept in News

1 topics

Frequently Asked Questions

6
1. What is the Motion of Thanks and what is its constitutional basis?

The Motion of Thanks is a formal way for Parliament to thank the President for their address at the beginning of a new parliamentary session or the first session of a new year. The President's address outlines the government's policies and achievements. As per Article 87 of the Indian Constitution, the President addresses both Houses of Parliament at the commencement of the first session after each general election and at the commencement of the first session of each year.

Exam Tip

Remember Article 87 is related to the President's address and the Motion of Thanks.

2. What are the key provisions associated with the Motion of Thanks?

The key provisions, as per the concept data, are: * The President's address is delivered at the commencement of the first session after each general election and at the commencement of the first session of each year. * The address outlines the government's policies, programs, and achievements during the preceding year and indicates the agenda for the upcoming year. * After the President's address, a Motion of Thanks is moved in each House of Parliament. * Members of Parliament (MPs) debate the motion, discussing the issues raised in the President's address. * Amendments to the motion can be proposed by MPs to express disagreement with the government's policies or to highlight specific issues.

  • The President's address is delivered at the commencement of the first session after each general election and at the commencement of the first session of each year.
  • The address outlines the government's policies, programs, and achievements during the preceding year and indicates the agenda for the upcoming year.
  • After the President's address, a Motion of Thanks is moved in each House of Parliament.
  • Members of Parliament (MPs) debate the motion, discussing the issues raised in the President's address.
  • Amendments to the motion can be proposed by MPs to express disagreement with the government's policies or to highlight specific issues.

Exam Tip

Focus on the sequence of events: President's address, followed by Motion of Thanks, debate, and potential amendments.

3. How has the Motion of Thanks evolved over time in India?

The Motion of Thanks, adopted after independence in 1950, was initially focused on thanking the President. Over time, it has evolved into a comprehensive discussion on government policies and performance. Recent developments, such as the extended debate on the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) in 2020, highlight this evolution.

Exam Tip

Note the shift from a simple formality to a significant platform for policy debate.

4. What is the significance of the Motion of Thanks in Indian democracy?

The Motion of Thanks is a crucial part of Indian parliamentary democracy because it provides a structured opportunity for Parliament to discuss and scrutinize the government's agenda as outlined by the President. The government must secure the passage of the Motion of Thanks in both Houses; failure to do so can indicate a lack of confidence in the government.

Exam Tip

Remember that the passage of the Motion of Thanks is essential for the government's stability.

5. How does the Motion of Thanks work in practice?

In practice, after the President delivers their address, a Member of Parliament moves a motion to thank the President. This motion is then debated upon. Members can propose amendments to the motion to express disagreement or highlight specific issues. The government must ensure the motion is passed in both Houses. Recent news highlights a departure from convention where the Prime Minister skipped the reply to the Motion of Thanks citing security concerns.

Exam Tip

Understand the procedural steps: moving the motion, debate, amendments, and voting.

6. What are the challenges in the implementation of the Motion of Thanks?

One challenge is the increasing disruption during the President's address and the subsequent debate on the Motion of Thanks, as noted in recent developments. This can hinder meaningful discussion and scrutiny of government policies. Another challenge is ensuring that the debate remains focused on the issues raised in the President's address, rather than devolving into unrelated political arguments.

Exam Tip

Consider how disruptions affect the quality of parliamentary debate and governance.

Source Topic

Parliamentary Accountability Eroded: PM Skips Reply, Citing Vague Security Concerns

Polity & Governance

UPSC Relevance

The Motion of Thanks is important for the UPSC exam, particularly for GS Paper 2 (Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International relations). Questions can be asked about its constitutional basis, significance, and the role it plays in parliamentary democracy. It is relevant for both Prelims (factual questions about Article 87) and Mains (analytical questions about its impact on government accountability). In recent years, questions have focused on the functioning of Parliament and the relationship between the executive and the legislature. For example, questions may ask about the implications of disruptions during the President's address or the role of the Speaker in maintaining order. Understanding the Motion of Thanks is crucial for analyzing current political events and debates.