What is Tax Devolution?
Historical Background
Key Points
10 points- 1.
Constitutional Mandate: Article 270 of the Indian Constitution mandates the sharing of certain taxes levied and collected by the Union with the States.
- 2.
Divisible Pool: The 'divisible pool' for tax devolution comprises all Union taxes and duties, except for cesses and surcharges, which are typically retained by the Centre.
- 3.
Vertical Devolution: The Finance Commission recommends the percentage share of the divisible pool that should go to the states as a whole (e.g., 41% by 15th FC).
- 4.
Horizontal Devolution: The Finance Commission also recommends the criteria for distributing the states' share among individual states. These criteria aim to address horizontal imbalances.
- 5.
Key Criteria for Horizontal Devolution (15th FC): Income Distance (45%), Population (15% for 2011 census), Area (15%), Forest & Ecology (10%), Demographic Performance (12.5%), Tax & Fiscal Effort (2.5%).
- 6.
Purpose: To ensure that states have adequate resources to fulfill their constitutional responsibilities, promote balanced regional development, and reduce both vertical and horizontal fiscal imbalances.
- 7.
Impact on States: States receive a significant portion of their revenue through tax devolution, which is untied funds, giving them flexibility in spending.
- 8.
Role of Finance Commission: The Finance Commission is the sole constitutional body responsible for recommending the principles and quantum of tax devolution.
- 9.
Difference from Grants-in-Aid: Unlike grants-in-aid (Article 275), which can be conditional or specific, tax devolution provides untied funds to states.
- 10.
GST Impact: The introduction of GST changed the nature of indirect tax sharing, but the principle of devolution for central taxes (like corporate income tax, personal income tax) remains crucial.
Visual Insights
Understanding Tax Devolution
This mind map outlines the key aspects of tax devolution in India, including its purpose, criteria, and constitutional basis.
Tax Devolution
- ●Purpose
- ●Criteria
- ●Constitutional Basis
- ●Divisible Pool
Recent Developments
4 developmentsThe 15th Finance Commission recommended a 41% share of the divisible pool for states for the period 2020-2025, a slight reduction from the 14th FC's 42% due to the conversion of Jammu & Kashmir into a Union Territory.
Increased concerns from states regarding the growing share of cesses and surcharges, which are not part of the divisible pool, thereby reducing the funds available for devolution.
Debates on the weightage given to various criteria for horizontal devolution, particularly population and income distance, affecting 'net contributor' states.
Impact of economic slowdown and COVID-19 on the overall tax buoyancy and, consequently, the quantum of funds available for devolution.
